Toothy’s Treasure is an interactive musical comedy about modern-day pirates. It follows a misfit crew on the journey to find a hidden fortune left behind by Captain Toothy. Being the first to Toothy’s Island sounds like an easy task until the crew’s beloved protagonist is abruptly murdered by navy sailors in the first scene. With no protagonist to hold the team together, the pirates decide to choose an audience volunteer with “main-character energy” to guide their way to the treasure.